red barn bakery how to order

Pies & cakes

whole pies and cakes, made to order.

Fruit pies with organic Hudson Valley fruit, pecan and chocolate pies, and celebration cakes, baked from scratch for your table.

Pies are pickup only. Celebration cakes are made to order for your date.

A golden double-crust fruit pie, juices bubbling through the hand-crimped crust, with more pies cooling behind it
Whole pies, by handBaked from scratch

Made from scratch

our pies.

Every pie is made from scratch with organic ingredients. Ask us which pies we can make gluten-free.

  • Chocolate pecan pies, one labeled gluten-free by hand

    GF Texas Chocolate Pecan

  • Texas pecan pie in its tin

    Texas Pecan

  • A blueberry pie in its bakery box, ready for pickup

    Boxed and ready

  • Small berry pies with lattice tops, juices running onto the parchment

    Berry pies

  • Apple
  • Apple Salted Caramel Crumb
  • Raspberry Ginger Pear
  • Texas Pecan
  • Texas Chocolate Pecan
  • Double Chocolate Fudge

With the seasons

pies that follow the farm stand.

This fall's pies
  • Strawberry rhubarb pie topped with fresh berries

    Strawberry Rhubarb

  • Blueberry lattice pie

    Blueberry

  • A cranberry tart with a crumb topping, dusted with sugar

    Cranberry tart

  • Four golden lattice pies on parchment, caramelized filling bubbling through

    Peach and apple caramel lattice

  • Strawberry Rhubarb
  • Blueberry
  • Peach
  • Peach Plum
  • Brown Butter Maple Pumpkin Chiffon

For your occasion

gluten-free and vegan, our specialty.

We bake traditional cakes too. Every celebration cake is made to order for your date, so please give us at least two days' notice.

  • Double Chocolate Layer Cakewith raspberry filling GFV
  • Lemon Olive Oil Cakewith pistachio cardamom buttercream GF
  • Semi-Naked Matcha CakeGFV
  • Semi-Naked Red Velvet CakeGFV
  • Strawberry Shortcaketraditional, in season
Plan your cake
Semi-naked vanilla cake with piped rosettes and rainbow sprinkles
Chocolate layer cake with piped chocolate rosettes
Layer cake with whipped cream and fresh strawberries
Lemon layer cake topped with strawberries and physalis

From the pastry case

tarts & cheesecakes.

  • Fruit tart with figs, strawberries and blackberries

    Seasonal Fruit Tart

  • Vegan blueberry cheesecake with fresh blueberries

    Vegan Blueberry Cheesecake

  • Layered pumpkin cheesecake topped with pecans

    Seasonal Cheesecake

three steps to your table.

  1. Pick your pie or cake

    Browse what's above, or ask us about something special.

  2. Order ahead

    Call us at (914) 231-7779 or stop by the counter. For a celebration cake, send us a cake request.

  3. Pick up in Irvington

    Collect your order at the counter, 4 South Astor Street, across from the Metro-North station. Pies are pickup only.

order ahead, pick up in irvington.